Introduce an analysis of Islam as a social and anthropological fact in relation to a comparative sociology of religions and symbolic systems. This analysis will be carried out with particular reference to European Muslim populations. Epistemological questions involving the study of the Muslim religion by anthropology and sociology. Brief introduction to the history of the Islamic religion, to the central points of its doctrine and institutions. Particular attention is paid to the dynamics of Islam in the last century.
Thanks for explaining what you meant by all that. I still have a couple of reservations with your examples though. Please bear with me. I can show this in a simple way: in order to become Spanish you have to accept and believe that he is the King, since you have to take an oath like in the case of the UK. So the criteria may change from case to case. Regarding this division between personal identity and social identity, I guess I see your point there. You say:. First of all, believing the Carlos I is the king of Spain is not a criterion for being Spanish.
Actually believing that Carlos I is the king of Spain is a necessary criterion for being Spanish. Yet to recognise that Carlos I is the king of Spain does not make you Spanish. So where is the difference? Certainly there is a theological difference but not a logical one. If I were to feel that I was Scottish, yet had no ties to Scotland in terms of nationality or ancestry, would would I still be Scottish?
The answer is certainly yes. Indeed you still confuse here two categories, the personal and the social.
Can Muslims Drink? Intoxicating the Anthropology of Islam
Socially, some people would deny that, since you do not have Scottish links, you are Scottish or at least a real one. The deniers will be, from your viewpoint, wrong in not recognising your own Scottishness. Let me extend these two examples which are just examples, in the book I discuss the topic in great detail to the case of Islam or any other religion.
For this reason, as Mamdani says , to speak of good Muslims and bad Muslims does not make sense. At least within anthropology. This argument is flawed.
If I were to feel that I was Scottish, yet had no ties to Scotland in terms of nationality or ancestry, would that still be Scottish? I am very much enthusiastic reading the extract. Thank you for sharing. All the best doc…. Pingback: The Anthropology of Islam. I wonder how relevant this might be to my proposed Autoethnographic Muslims Studies AMS , crudely a autobiographical exploration of identity which draws heavily on discourses from the social sciences and Islamic Studies.
You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account.
Anthropology of Islam - Anthropology - Oxford Bibliographies
You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. Widgets Search. Like this: Like Loading Everybody ignore.
Emotions, piousness and lack of intellectual genealogy Islam, Muslims, and an Anthropologist Dear Prof. Marranchi, Reading all the comments above I have lots of questions to ask anthropoligists. December 29, at am Reply. March 16, at pm Reply.
- Sword of Darkness (Lords of Avalon).
- 1st Edition.
- Everyday Islam.
- Investigations in Yeast Functional Genomics and Molecular Biology.
July 31, at pm Reply. August 3, at am Reply. July 8, at am Reply. Kia Ora good day in Maori , My class and I read your article about the controversy in Scotland over the puppy. So why did Clr. Asif even raise the point in the first place? Kia Kaha stand strong.
- The Idea of an Anthropology of Islam | Asad | Islamology;
- Religious Matters - Can Muslims Drink? Intoxicating the Anthropology of Islam?
- Top Authors!
- Interview with John Bowen on “A New Anthropology of Islam” | CritCom;
- Everyday Islam | Cultural Anthropology.
- Sports Supplements: Which Nutritional Supplements Really Work!
- Go to Page.
July 7, at pm Reply. May 23, at pm Reply. Dear JDsg, Of course, for theological aspects of Islam, objects submit to Allah, but since objects do not have conciousness, they cannot express Islam.
Anthropology in Islam
April 18, at am Reply. ANT: There is no Islam without mind. Hi Doc, Thanks for explaining what you meant by all that. April 5, at pm Reply. Dear Rasheed, thanks for your comments and criticism. You say: First of all, believing the Carlos I is the king of Spain is not a criterion for being Spanish. I hope that this may clarify the point. March 21, at pm Reply. STU: Yes, Doc. ANT: Are you Spanish?
STU: Of course not.
Dr Ashraf Hoque
University of California Press, Tarlo and A. London: Bloomsbury, Cambridge University Press. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research , Cosmopolitanisms in Muslim Contexts: Perspectives from the Past. Edinburgh University Press. Persian wine tradition and symbolism: Evidence from the medieval poetry of Hafiz.
Journal of Wine Research , 15 2 : Material Religion , 8 3 : Bearman, Th. Bianquis, C. Bosworth, E.